Sorry. couldn’t resist. It’s actually a TyTN II and you’d not want to clash with this heavyweight in the smartphone arena.
It’s not that my mobile phone addiction has finally got out of control, but the last few weeks I’ve been lucky enough to have got my hands on a number of new toys to play with (sadly apart from my Shadow they all have to go back eventually).
It’s been interesting to compare the BlackJack II (smartphone – non-touch device) to the less powerful Shadow (also a smartphone) and see how they stack up to my previous touch based device (the Wizard) and the fully loaded TyTN II (a “Windows Mobile Professional” – i.e. Touchscreen - device).
Aside the most obvious feature – the tilting screen when you slide the keyboard out (probably why the AT&T branded version is called the “Tilt”!) – this really is a phone with everything. 3MP camera, front facing video conferencing camera, 2.5 and 3G data, 802.11b and g WiFi, Bluetooth 2.0, Assisted GPS, a scroll wheel (should be mandatory on any device where I have to read lists) … everything bar the kitchen sink (Frank has a nice post with the specs).
Side by side it’s actually no bigger than my old Wizard, but it’s certainly packed with state of the art hardware. The processor is the same as the BJ II so it’s fast (the only thing I’ve noticed it slow down on is rotating the screen from landscape to portrait, but it’s over in a moment) and the memory capacity means it multi-tasks quite happily. There’s a full suite of apps on the device by default, and of course there are many, many Windows Mobile applications out there to solve most problems.
I’ve been using this beastie as my everyday phone and I really like it. But I don’t love it. Some people say it’s too large, but I got used to the Wizard. Some people say it’s overkill, but I love the features. The real reason is that I’ve been spoilt by the slowest and probably least capable of the devices. My Shadow.
On paper everything about the TyTN II is better. As a PDA or even a PC replacement I’d not argue for a moment (heck it’s almost as easy to do email and read Word documents on this thing as on my UMPC)… but as a phone I find a touch device that needs a stylus just doesn’t work as well for me. I know I can mash a finger on the screen but it just doesn’t feel right. I like the tactile feedback I get on the Shadow. HTC have done a great job of the interface – in fact I’ll happily continue using it until it goes back – but not enough to get me past like.
Comparing the BJ II and the TyTN II I think the smartphone wouldn’t come out on top. The keypad is just a little too fiddly, the lack of WiFi and a non standard charge/sync cable certainly don’t count in it’s favor (and needing to hack the WiFi to get it to work – thanks AT&T for crippling it). Comparing Shadow to BJ II (just to round it out), if the former had GPS there would be no question. As it stands – for me – the Shadow wins (I can always get a Bluetooth GPS device)… slide out 20 key keypad, mini USB charger, great form factor and WiFi.
Luckily HTC have shown that they know what the answer is… the HTC Touch Dual. Sadly in it’s current version the specs don’t match up to the Tytn II (in fact in some areas the Shadow beats it) but it gives me hope for the future…
In the meantime the TyTN II stays on my hip with the Shadow as “backup”. When the Tytn II goes back, the Shadow will be my primary device with the BlackJack II as backup….. until I get another device and have to rate them all over again ;)
If you’re thinking about a TyTN II check out some of the user sites for an unbiased view. TiltSite, HTCTilt and XDA_Developers are great community sites. TiltDepot is the place to go for accessories. If, like me, you can’t resist tweaking there’s a great tool for the Tytn II to get you started ;)